Report thread discussion.

[JIN18]

Since 2012, this target bug has never been part of the PvP protection — it only appeared recently.
Also, abusing a bug is against the game rules.
As a player, I have the right to report anyone who uses bugs like you do, because it ruins the game.
Just because you spend a few dollars doesn’t mean you are allowed to exploit bugs.

Wiered ppls.

I have never considered it a bug. This is because I am unable to attack you. Furthermore, I only started properly playing the game in May of this year, so I cannot understand what you are talking about

[JIN18]

I have searched the forum posts by users regarding this topic and confirmed that the relevant posts have been neglected for at least two years without any action or official statement from the GM or developers. This suggests that it is part of the game. If it were a bug, as you claim, there would have been some kind of response. Therefore, you should have used a different forum board (Suggestions and New Idea) rather than reporting an innocent user.
I believe the report filed against me is a false report, and I plan to compile the relevant details and inquire with the developers or GMs

[JIN18]

I don't know what country you live in, but in a capitalist era, game developers are not philanthropists. You might have thought the game development was finished once it was released, but that's not the case. There are things like server maintenance costs, which fluctuate proportionally to the number of users connected. The more users, the more the costs increase.
Therefore, the longer you connect, the more costs the developer has to bear. Yet, you and JINNX are the cause of increasing costs for the developer while not investing a single penny into the game, and you are full of complaints, demanding corrections and the labor of the developer. What effort have you put into this game? Someone like you who, along with JINNX, gets pleasure from accumulating points by killing innocent players?
A developer is neither an unpaid worker nor someone who lends out a server for free. It is unreasonable to demand their labor simply because you are at a disadvantage, and not because it is a critical bug in the game.

[Ayoub]

Look at how you're trying to make using a bug sound normal.
Is this your first time playing an MMO game?
You either look dumb or you're pretending to be.
Every MMO game has rules — whether you pay or not. If you break the rules, you get jailed or banned.

According to your logic, developers should let everyone pay to access bugs?
There is no game on the Play Store that allows that.

"Innocent players"? What do you mean? It's a PvP game — you can kill anyone, and they can kill you too.
what i give to this game is out of the report subject ( don't want to say how many dollars/time i spent or being a translator or game tester i even helped in some of the maps u using and u want us to accept the bugs ? xD )
I suggest you read the rules again.

If the GMs don't fix those bugs and punish the players who abuse them, then everyone will keep using them until the game lose it's value.

End of the discussion for me.

[JIN18]

I must reiterate, I have never considered this to be a bug. The standard PVP protection is functioning correctly if it prevents me from attacking others while I am also protected from being attacked. If I could attack you unilaterally, that would be a critical bug. I can place a mark, but I can't attack you. You are stubbornly insisting, without any logical basis, that "this is a bug" simply because you are at a disadvantage. Please stop crying you not a kid

[JIN18]

I am bringing forth evidence and reasons to explain this to you, yet you are simply being stubborn with me.
I mentioned earlier that posts regarding this issue have been on the forum for two years. The GM and developers have not taken any action (because this is part of the game and not a bug). Even if the developers did not implement a patch, they could have simply established a rule forbidding it, much like the 3-pet bug, where we can use it but are told not to. However, they did not take any action. If, as you claim, this was a bug, then this game has been neglected for two years, causing its value to drop, hasn't it? If that's how you feel, then stop whining and leave. It might seem unfair to you, but this is part of the game.

[JIN18]

I am writing to formally object to Lockwood's opinion concerning the "PVP Protect" item.
​Lockwood claims that a user with PVP Protect being able to place a mark (target) on another character is a bug. However, a PVP Protected user still cannot attack the marked target. The argument that this feature breaks game balance is weak, as a Mage can simply unequip their staff and still follow and assist with healing. Therefore, this is less of a bug and more of an increased convenience for paying users (or those using the feature).
​Furthermore, this specific topic was first mentioned approximately two years ago. The rules were most recently updated just five months ago, on June 2, 2025, yet the GM and the developers made no mention of this issue. If it were truly a bug, as Lockwood suggests, they could have at least released a statement or implemented a patch when updating the rules. This strongly suggests that this feature has been clearly accepted as a part of the game.
​Lockwood is arguing, without any solid basis, that a PVP Protected user should be blindly prevented from placing marks. If his logic is that a PVP Protected user should be unable to mark others because they are supposed to be avoiding PvP, then by that same logic, a PVP Protected user should not even be able to use a heal spell on another player. As far as I know, before the marking feature was introduced, PVP Protected users could use heal spells on others. Under his own logic, the "bug" already existed even before the marking feature was available.
​To conclude:
​Making assumptions without logic or evidence, simply because one feels disadvantaged, and refusing to acknowledge an accepted part of the game does not help make the game better. You are not a child. Stop whining.

[JIN18]

I dont know what happening but Account sharing is indeed illegal in this game. However, the action of using chats from a time when there was mutual trust—remaining silent back then only to file a report now to satisfy current feelings—is truly disgusting

[Nicole-_-]

I agree with Jin20, if you're AWARE of someone sharing/trading, and you're giving them tips and stuff to be better to assist you at the game up until you feel like you dont want them anymore you should be punished also.

[JIN18]

Looking at the conversation, he didn't just allow it; he actively participated in it